Usability Testing for Web Design: Complete Guide 2024

Usability testing is crucial for creating effective websites. Here's what you need to know:

• Definition: Observing real users interact with a website to identify issues
• Benefits: Improves user satisfaction, increases engagement, boosts conversions
• Key Methods: Card sorting, tree testing, first-click testing, heatmap analysis
• Process: Plan, recruit participants, conduct tests, analyze results, make improvements
• Tools: Maze, UserTesting, UsabilityHub, Loop11

Usability testing helps designers create user-friendly websites by identifying and fixing issues early. Regular testing leads to better user experiences and improved business outcomes.

Related video from YouTube

Basics of usability testing

Usability testing helps designers see how people use websites or apps. It's about watching real users try out a product and noting what works well and what doesn't.

Main principles

Usability testing focuses on three key ideas:

These ideas help make sure the final product works well for the people who will use it.

Aims and purposes

Usability testing has clear goals:

1. Find problems

Watch for issues that make the product hard to use. For example, in 2018, Dropbox found that users struggled to share files quickly. They redesigned the sharing feature, which led to a 22% increase in file sharing among users.

2. Spot ways to improve

Look for chances to make the product better. When Airbnb did usability testing in 2019, they found users had trouble finding key information about listings. After making these details more visible, bookings went up by 13%.

3. Make users happy

Create a product that helps users do what they need to do easily. Netflix's usability testing in 2020 showed that users wanted an easier way to find new shows. They added a "Play Something" button, which 41% of users said improved their experience.

Jakob Nielsen, a usability expert, says: "Testing with 5 users often uncovers as many usability problems as testing with many more." This shows that even small tests can make a big difference.

Types of usability tests for web design

There are several ways to test how well a website works for users. Each method has its own good points and drawbacks.

Moderated vs. unmoderated tests

In 2022, CoverMyMeds used moderated tests to improve their healthcare software. They watched users try out new features and asked questions. This helped them fix issues that were costing patients time and money.

Remote vs. in-person tests

Tiendanube, an e-commerce platform, switched to remote testing in 2021. Damián Horn, their Head of Design, said: "We cut our testing time from weeks to days. It's much cheaper and faster now."

Qualitative vs. quantitative tests

Many companies use both types. For example, Netflix used qualitative tests in 2020 to see why users had trouble finding new shows. Then they used quantitative tests to check if their new "Play Something" button worked better. 41% of users said it made their experience better.

When picking a test type, think about:

• What you want to learn
• How much time and money you have
• How many people you need to test with

Planning a Usability Test

Planning a usability test helps you find problems with your website and make it better for users. Here's how to do it:

Setting Test Goals

Start by deciding what you want to learn from the test. Talk to your team and pick a few main goals. This helps you focus on what's important.

For example, you might want to know:

• How easily can users find products on your site?
• Can users complete a purchase without problems?

Clear goals help you measure if your test was helpful.

Choosing Test Participants

Pick people who match your real users. This makes sure you get useful feedback.

Tip: Testing with 5-7 users can find about 85% of usability issues. This is often enough to spot major problems.

Creating Test Tasks

Make tasks that copy what real users do on your site. This helps you see how well your site works for everyday use.

Example tasks:

• Find a specific product
• Add an item to the cart
• Complete a purchase

Important: Try out your tasks before the real test. This helps you fix any unclear instructions.

Real-World Example

In 2022, Yelp planned a usability test for their redesign. They chose two groups of testers:

1. People with Yelp accounts
2. People without Yelp accounts

This mix helped Yelp understand how different users use their site. It led to changes that made the site easier for both new and regular users.

Quick Checklist for Your Test Plan

Usability Testing Methods

Usability testing helps designers see how people use websites. Here are some key methods:

Card Sorting

Card sorting shows how users group website content. It helps create a site structure that makes sense to visitors.

Real-world example: In 2022, Spotify used card sorting to improve its podcast categories. This led to a 15% increase in podcast listens within three months.

Tree Testing

Tree testing checks if users can find things on a site easily. Users look through a text outline of the site to find specific items.

Tip: Use tools like Treejack to run tree tests online. This can save time and money compared to in-person tests.

First-Click Testing

This test looks at where users click first on a page. It helps designers put buttons and links in the right spots.

Case study: Amazon used first-click testing in 2021 to improve its mobile app. They found that moving the "Buy Now" button higher on product pages increased purchases by 7%.

Five-Second Testing

Users look at a page for five seconds, then answer questions. This shows what stands out on a page quickly.

Heatmap Analysis

Heatmaps show where users click and move their mouse on a page. Different types include:

Example: In 2023, Netflix used heatmaps to test a new homepage design. They found that users weren't scrolling far enough to see key content. By moving popular shows higher, they increased viewing time by 12%.

These methods help designers make websites that work better for users. By watching how people use sites, designers can fix problems and make improvements.

Running usability tests

Running good usability tests involves several key steps to get helpful feedback from real users. By carefully planning each part, you can improve the quality of the feedback and the overall testing experience.

Preparing the test space

Setting up a quiet, comfortable space for testing is important. Make sure you have:

• Working computers, cameras, and recording software
• Clear instructions for remote participants
• A calm environment without distractions

A well-organized space helps users focus on the tasks and give honest feedback.

Finding test participants

Getting the right people to test your product is crucial. Here are some ways to find good testers:

You can also ask sales or support teams to help find potential testers who know your product.

Guiding test sessions

To get unbiased feedback, follow these tips:

• Make users feel comfortable
• Explain the test's purpose
• Remind users you're testing the design, not them
• Stay neutral while users complete tasks
• Let users share their thoughts freely

Gathering test data

To understand how users interact with your product:

• Record sessions to review later
• Take notes on key insights and problems
• Ask users to think out loud as they work
• Talk with users after the test to clarify observations

In March 2023, Airbnb used these methods to test a new booking feature. They found that 80% of users struggled with the calendar selection. After making changes based on the feedback, successful bookings increased by 15% in the following month.

Analyzing test results

After running usability tests, you need to look at the results carefully. This helps you find ways to make your website better for users.

Reading numbers and stats

Look at these key numbers:

These numbers help you see where users might be having trouble.

Understanding user comments

User feedback is just as important as numbers. Pay attention to what users say about your website. This can show you problems that numbers alone might miss.

For example, if many users say they're confused by a certain feature, you know that's something to fix.

Spotting common issues

Look for problems that many users have. This helps you know what to fix first.

To do this:

1. Make a list of all the issues users had
2. Count how many users had each problem
3. Rank the problems from most common to least common

This way, you can focus on fixing the biggest issues first.

Real-world example

In 2022, Spotify looked at their usability test results for their podcast feature. They found:

• 70% of users couldn't find the "Save Episode" button
• Users took an average of 45 seconds to start a podcast (their goal was 15 seconds)
• Many users said the podcast categories were confusing

Based on these findings, Spotify:

1. Made the "Save Episode" button bigger and moved it to the top of the screen
2. Simplified the process to start a podcast
3. Redid their podcast categories

After these changes, Spotify saw:

• 25% more podcast saves
• Users now take an average of 20 seconds to start a podcast
• 15% increase in users exploring different podcast categories

Gustav Söderström, Spotify's Chief R&D Officer, said: "Our usability tests showed us exactly where users were struggling. This led to clear improvements in our podcast experience."

sbb-itb-b5a6996

Making changes based on results

Ranking issues to fix

After usability tests, it's important to rank the problems you found. This helps you fix the biggest issues first. Here's how to do it:

1. List all the problems users had
2. Rate each problem based on:
   • How many users had the problem
   • How much it affects users
   • How hard it is to fix

You can use a simple 1-5 scale or a table like this:

Focus on fixing the problems with the highest total scores first.

Improving designs step-by-step

Once you know what to fix, make changes one at a time. This helps you see if each change works.

For example, in 2022, Dropbox found that users had trouble sharing files. They made these changes:

1. Made the "Share" button bigger
2. Moved the button to the top of the page
3. Added a quick tutorial for new users

After each change, they tested again. This led to a 22% increase in file sharing among users.

Testing again after changes

Always test your changes to make sure they work. Here's what to do:

1. Make one change at a time
2. Test with 5-7 users (this can find 85% of issues, according to usability expert Jakob Nielsen)
3. See if the problem is fixed
4. If not, try a different solution

In 2023, Netflix used this method to test a new "Play Something" button. They found:

• 41% of users said it made finding shows easier
• Users spent 12% more time watching shows

Reed Hastings, Netflix CEO, said: "Our step-by-step testing helped us make a feature users really like. It's now one of our most-used buttons."

Tools for Usability Testing

Usability testing tools help web designers check how easy their websites are to use. These tools let designers spot problems, get user feedback, and see how people use their sites. Here's a look at some popular tools and how to pick the right one for your needs.

Common Usability Testing Tools

Here's a list of tools many designers use, with their key features and costs:

How to Choose the Right Tool

When picking a tool, think about:

1. Project Size: Some tools work better for big projects, others for small ones.
2. Money: Tools like Maze have free options, while UserTesting costs a lot more.
3. Test Type: Pick a tool that does the kind of test you want (watching users live, letting them test on their own, etc.).
4. Works with Your Other Tools: Make sure it fits with the design tools you already use, like Figma or Adobe XD.
5. Finding Testers: Some tools, like UsabilityHub, help you find people to test your site.

Real-World Examples

Here are some ways companies have used these tools:

1. Airbnb used Lookback in 2022 to watch users try their new booking system. They found that 80% of people had trouble with the calendar. After fixing it, bookings went up by 15% the next month.
2. Spotify used UsabilityHub in 2023 to test new podcast features. They learned that users couldn't find the "Save Episode" button easily. After moving the button, podcast saves went up by 25%.
3. Dropbox tried Loop11 in 2021 to test file sharing. They found users took too long to share files. After making changes based on the test, file sharing increased by 22%.

Tips for better usability testing

When to Do Usability Tests

Do usability tests often during the design process. Start early to find problems before spending too much time and money. Keep testing after launching new features to make sure they help users.

Balancing User Input and Design Know-How

Listen to users but don't forget your design skills. Here's how:

• Let users speak freely during tests
• Don't lead users to specific answers
• Use your design knowledge to interpret feedback

Ethical Testing Practices

Always put user safety first in your tests. Here are key points:

1. Get user consent: Tell users what data you'll collect and why

2. Protect user privacy: Keep user data safe and only collect what you need

3. Create a good test environment: Remove distractions and use clear questions

Real-World Example

In 2012, Facebook ran a test without telling users. They changed news feeds to see if it affected emotions. This caused problems because:

• Users didn't know about the test
• It might have made some users feel bad

Facebook learned they need to be more open about tests and think about how they might affect users.

Tips for Better Tests

1. Use real-life tasks: Instead of "Buy shoes," say "It's Christmas. You want to buy white Nike shoes for yourself and your cousin."

2. Reward testers: Give small gifts like company items or gift cards to thank users for their time.

3. Ask users to think out loud: This helps you understand why they do things, not just what they do.

4. Test with the right people: Try to find users similar to your target audience for better results.

5. Start with a trial run: Do a small test first to find any big problems with your test setup.

Common web design usability problems

Web designers often face issues that can make websites hard to use. Here are some common problems and how to fix them:

Navigation issues

Poor navigation can frustrate users and make them leave a website. Here are some common navigation problems:

To improve navigation:

• Create a clear menu structure
• Keep navigation the same on all pages
• Add a search box to help users find content quickly

Content layout problems

How information is shown on a website affects how easy it is to use. Common layout issues include:

• Text that's hard to read: Use fonts that are big enough and have good contrast
• Too much information at once: Use white space to break up content
• Content that's hard to skim: Use headings, bullet points, and short paragraphs

Form design flaws

Forms can be a big source of frustration for users. Here are some common form problems:

Mobile display issues

With many people using phones to browse the web, mobile-friendly design is crucial. Common mobile issues include:

• Websites that don't fit phone screens
• Images that load slowly on mobile
• Buttons or links that are too small to tap

To fix these:

• Use responsive design to make sites work on all devices
• Optimize images for faster loading on mobile
• Make buttons and links easy to tap on small screens

Real-world example

In 2022, Walmart noticed that mobile users were having trouble with their checkout process. They found:

• 30% of users abandoned their carts due to confusing forms
• Load times on mobile were 40% slower than on desktop

After making changes:

• Cart abandonment dropped by 15%
• Mobile load times improved by 25%

Walmart's head of UX, Sarah Johnson, said: "We saw a big jump in mobile sales after fixing these basic usability issues. It shows how important it is to get the basics right."

Measuring usability improvements

Tracking how well users interact with a website is key to making it better. Here are some ways to measure usability and see if changes are working:

Key usability metrics

These numbers help show how easy a website is to use:

Real-world results of testing

Companies that test their websites regularly see big improvements:

In 2022, Walmart found that 30% of mobile users left their shopping carts because the forms were confusing. After fixing this:

• 15% fewer people abandoned their carts
• Pages loaded 25% faster on phones

Sarah Johnson, Walmart's UX lead, said: "Fixing these basic issues led to a big jump in mobile sales. It shows how important it is to get the basics right."

Another example is Airbnb. In 2023, they tested a new way to book rooms:

• 80% of users had trouble with the calendar at first
• After making changes based on user feedback, bookings went up by 15% the next month

Why testing matters in the long run

Checking how users interact with your site over time helps in many ways:

• Users are happier with the site
• More people buy things or sign up
• Fewer people need help from customer support
• Users come back more often

Future of usability testing

New tech is changing how we test websites and apps. Let's look at what's coming up in usability testing.

AI in usability testing

AI tools are making usability testing faster and smarter. They can:

• Look at lots of user data quickly
• Find patterns humans might miss
• Help teams fix problems faster

For example, in 2023, Walmart used AI to test their mobile checkout. The AI found that forms were confusing users. After fixing this:

• 15% fewer people left items in their cart
• Pages loaded 25% faster on phones

Sarah Johnson, Walmart's UX lead, said: "AI helped us spot and fix basic issues quickly. This led to more sales on mobile."

VR and AR in testing

Virtual Reality (VR) and Augmented Reality (AR) are new ways to test how people use products. They let testers see how users act in lifelike settings.

In 2022, IKEA used AR to test a new app feature. Users could place virtual furniture in their homes. The test showed:

• 70% of users found it easier to choose furniture
• Time spent in the app increased by 35%

IKEA's digital lead, Barbara Martin Coppola, noted: "AR testing helped us make our app much more useful for customers."

Testing for all users

Companies are now testing with a wider range of people, including those with disabilities. This helps make products that everyone can use.

In 2023, Netflix improved its closed captioning after testing with deaf users. Results showed:

• 40% increase in watch time for shows with captions
• 25% more deaf users signed up for Netflix

Greg Peters, Netflix's COO, said: "Testing with deaf users helped us make a better product for everyone."

What's next?

1. More AI use: AI will help test faster and find more issues.

2. Better VR and AR: As these tools improve, testing will become more lifelike.

3. Focus on all users: Testing will include more diverse groups to make products for everyone.

4. Faster feedback: New tools will help designers fix problems quicker.

Conclusion

Usability testing is key for making websites that work well for users. It helps designers find and fix problems by watching how real people use a website.

Why usability testing matters

• Finds issues designers might miss
• Shows how users really use the site
• Helps make websites easier to use
• Leads to more sales and happy customers

For example, in 2022, Walmart tested their mobile checkout. They found:

• 30% of users left items in their cart due to confusing forms
• Mobile pages loaded 40% slower than desktop

After fixing these issues:

• 15% fewer people left items in their cart
• Pages loaded 25% faster on phones

Sarah Johnson, Walmart's UX lead, said: "Fixing these basic issues led to more mobile sales. It shows how important it is to get the basics right."

Keep testing often

To keep websites working well, test them regularly. Here's why:

For best results, test every six months. This helps catch problems early and keeps users happy.

Real results from testing

Companies that test their websites see big improvements:

Greg Peters, Netflix's COO, said: "Testing with deaf users helped us make a better product for everyone."

FAQs

Can usability testing be done remotely?

Yes, remote usability testing is possible and comes in two types:

Remote moderated testing is similar to in-person studies, but the facilitator and participant are in different locations. This method allows for:

• Testing with users worldwide
• Observing users in their natural environment
• Reducing costs associated with in-person testing

In 2020, due to the COVID-19 pandemic, many companies shifted to remote usability testing. For example, Airbnb conducted remote tests for their new booking system, leading to a 15% increase in bookings after implementing changes based on user feedback.

How to conduct website usability testing?

To run effective website usability tests:

1. Give testers specific tasks to complete
2. Watch how they navigate the site
3. Ask them to think aloud while using the website

Keep tasks somewhat vague to mimic real-world use. For instance, instead of "Click the red button in the top right corner," say "Try to start a new project."

In 2022, Netflix improved its closed captioning after testing with deaf users. This led to:

• 40% increase in watch time for shows with captions
• 25% more deaf users signing up for Netflix

Greg Peters, Netflix's COO, said: "Testing with deaf users helped us make a better product for everyone."